Home » By Course » Drinks » Stovetop Eggnog Creamer

Stovetop Eggnog Creamer

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

This homemade eggnog creamer is plain half-and-half warmed in a saucepan with sugar, a pinch of salt, nutmeg, vanilla, and rum extract. Each splash turns coffee creamy and nutmeg-spiced, with no eggs anywhere in the jar.
5 from 50 votes
Prep Time 5 minutes
Total Time 55 minutes
Servings 21 (1-tablespoon) servings; 1.75 cups
A glass mug of coffee or tea topped with spices, sitting on a wooden board next to a lidded jar and a striped napkin.

Most homemade eggnog creamers start with a can of sweetened condensed milk, and plenty add a carton of store-bought eggnog too. That makes the creamer only as good as the eggnog you found, and only possible while eggnog is on the shelf. This version needs neither, so it tastes the same in January as it does in December, and you decide how sweet it gets.

One reader, Elaine, commented: “I can’t wait to try this. I love eggnog but never thought I could make a creamer that tastes like it. Perfect. ★★★★★”

Another reader, Alex, commented: “This was amazing! And I didn’t even use the rum extract. I’m going to make some more right now to give out as presents. Thanks so much! ★★★★★”

A glass mug of coffee or tea topped with spices, sitting on a wooden board next to a lidded jar and a striped napkin.

I cook this one on the stove because that’s what makes it feel homemade to me: warm the dairy, stir in the sugar, then add the flavorings off the heat. It’s the same stovetop instinct behind boiled custard, eggnog’s plainer cousin, just without the eggs or the hours in the fridge.

How to Make Eggnog Coffee Creamer

Set the pan over medium heat and stay with it. The half-and-half takes about 2 minutes to start steaming, with small bubbles forming around the edge of the pan, and that’s your cue to move on. Don’t let it boil, or it can scorch on the bottom or foam up and over the sides.

Stir in the sugar and salt next, and keep stirring until your spoon scrapes the bottom of the pan clean of any grains. Then take the pan off the heat before the vanilla and nutmeg go in, and whisk the rum extract in last.

Let the creamer cool for about 45 minutes, until it’s cool enough to pour into a jar, then refrigerate it. One batch makes about 1⅓ cups, roughly 21 tablespoon-size splashes. Check the printable recipe card below for the full ingredient list, measurements, and step-by-step instructions.

Shake it before every pour. In testing, the nutmeg settled to the bottom of the jar, the way the snow in a snow globe settles once it stops moving. A quick shake brings the spice back up through the cream before it goes into your cup.

Ingredient Notes

Half-and-half. It’s the only dairy in the recipe, and it’s what lets this creamer skip the can and the carton. It comes up to steam quickly, which is why the pan needs you standing next to it.

Sugar. The card’s ⅓ cup is the starting point, and since you’re making it yourself, the sweetness is yours to set. I always found Coffee Mate’s eggnog creamer too sweet, and unless I was really short on time, I made my own.

Ground nutmeg. This is where the eggnog flavor comes from, at ½ teaspoon for the batch.

Rum extract. It still contains alcohol, even though it’s sold as a flavoring. If kids will be drinking it in hot chocolate, make that batch without it.

Salt. The pinch is measured as fine table salt, about 1/16 teaspoon.

Can You Put Eggnog in Coffee?

Yes. Real eggnog works in coffee when that’s what’s in the fridge. It pours thicker than creamer, though, and it brings a stronger egg flavor to the cup. That’s the gap this creamer fills: the nutmeg and vanilla of eggnog with no eggs in it at all.

If you want eggnog to drink on its own, this homemade non-alcoholic eggnog is the cooked, egg-yolk version.

Eggnog creamer being poured from a glass into a glass mug of coffee on a wooden board.

Serving and Storing

Stir a splash into hot coffee, then add more to taste. It goes into cold brew the same way. If you brew a pot of Christmas blend coffee, with cinnamon and cardamom mixed into the grounds, this creamer goes right in on top.

Froth your coffee? The milk frother wand guide covers how. For something sweeter, stir a little toffee nut syrup into the same cup.

Outside of coffee, it suits a cup of black tea or hot chocolate.

A glass jar of eggnog creamer with a chalkboard label, sitting on a wooden board next to a mug of coffee.

For a holiday gift, pour it into a clean glass jar or bottle with a tag, and pair it with a jar of peppermint mocha coffee creamer so there are two flavors to choose from. More ideas for the season are in my Christmas recipes collection.

Keep the creamer covered in the refrigerator in a glass jar or bottle, and finish it before the date printed on the half-and-half you opened.

A glass mug of coffee or tea topped with spices, sitting on a wooden board next to a lidded jar and a striped napkin.

Homemade Eggnog Creamer

Author: Jessica Haggard
This homemade eggnog creamer is plain half-and-half warmed in a saucepan with sugar, a pinch of salt, nutmeg, vanilla, and rum extract. Each splash turns coffee creamy and nutmeg-spiced, with no eggs anywhere in the jar.
5 from 50 votes
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 5 minutes
Cool Time 45 minutes
Total Time 55 minutes
Course Drinks
Cuisine American
Servings 21 (1-tablespoon) servings; 1.75 cups
Calories 35 kcal

Equipment

  • Small saucepan
  • Spoon
  • whisk
  • Airtight glass jar or bottle

Ingredients
 
 

Instructions
 

  • Warm the half-and-half in a small saucepan over medium heat until steam rises and small bubbles form at the edge of the pan, about 2 minutes. Do not let it boil, so it does not scorch or boil over.
    A saucepan filled with a creamy, pale yellow liquid sits on a stovetop burner.
  • Stir in the sugar and salt until no sugar granules remain when you scrape the bottom of the pan with a spoon.
    A wooden spoon stirs a creamy, light-colored sauce in a saucepan on a stovetop.
  • Remove the pan from the heat, then whisk in the vanilla extract and nutmeg. Whisk in the rum extract last.
    A hand whisks a creamy, speckled mixture in a metal saucepan on a marble surface.
  • Let the creamer cool, then transfer it to an airtight glass jar or bottle and refrigerate.
    A glass jar of eggnog creamer on a wooden cutting board next to a red checkered cloth, whole nutmeg, and cinnamon sticks.

Notes

Yield is about 1 1/3 cups.
Serve: Add a spoonful or two to hot coffee, cold brew, black tea, or hot chocolate, more to taste. A light dusting of ground nutmeg finishes the mug.
Store: Keep it in a sealed glass jar in the refrigerator and use it by the date on the half-and-half. The nutmeg settles as it sits, so give the jar a shake before each pour.

Nutrition

Serving: 1tablespoonCalories: 35kcalCarbohydrates: 4gProtein: 1gFat: 2gSaturated Fat: 1gPolyunsaturated Fat: 0.1gMonounsaturated Fat: 1gCholesterol: 6mgSodium: 18mgPotassium: 23mgFiber: 0.01gSugar: 4gVitamin A: 61IUVitamin C: 0.2mgCalcium: 19mgIron: 0.01mg
Did you make this recipe?Please leave a review and share your experience with us! Your feedback means a lot to the entire community.

Similar Posts

5 from 50 votes (48 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




19 Comments

  1. I love eggnog and this creamer is great for when I can no longer get it in the stores. It gave all of the great eggnog flavors for my coffee.

  2. This creamer was delicious in our coffee this morning! can’t wait to use it again tomorrow. The rum extract is such a great idea!

  3. 5 stars
    This was amazing! And I didn’t even use the rum extract. I’m going to make some more right now to give out as presents. Thanks so much!

  4. What a fun flavor idea for a coffee creamer for the holidays! I might have to add a little more rum to mine though. 😉

  5. LOVE this creamer… it sure makes making tasty coffee a lot easier. I’ve made a few batches to give to close friends as well.

  6. Last year I used leftover eggnog as an addition to my coffee and loved it. This recipe is a awesome shortcut. Between this and the Xmas coffee blend, my family will be very happy when they stay at my house for the holidays this year.