13 Cozy Fall Pies Grandma Secretly Loves More Than Apple Pie

Apple pie is great, but let’s be honest, Grandma has a few fall favorites she secretly loves even more. These cozy pies are easier to make, packed with bold seasonal flavors, and guaranteed to steal the show at any gathering. If you’re tired of the same old desserts and want something that actually gets people talking and asking for seconds, these are the pies to bake.

Peanut Butter Pie

Peanut butter pie is a no-bake dream that combines chocolate and peanut butter into one creamy, indulgent dessert. Made with only six ingredients, it’s rich without being complicated, and perfect for when you want something that feels special but takes little effort. Grandma knows this is one pie that rivals apple for pure comfort.
Get the Recipe: Peanut Butter Pie

Cinnamon Roll Pie

Cinnamon roll pie layers gooey, sweet rolls inside a buttery crust and tops them with frosting for a dessert that doubles as breakfast. It’s a Cracker Barrel-inspired treat that feels nostalgic and fun, perfect for family gatherings or lazy weekends. Grandma secretly loves this because it brings all the cozy fall vibes with minimal fuss.
Get the Recipe: Cinnamon Roll Pie

Blackberry Galette

Blackberry galette is rustic, simple, and bursting with sweet-tart berry flavor wrapped in a buttery crust. Using frozen berries and refrigerated dough makes it look impressive without extra effort. Grandma loves how it feels both homemade and elegant, a perfect twist on the usual fall dessert spread.
Get the Recipe: Blackberry Galette

Chocolate Cream Pie

Chocolate cream pie is all about comfort, with its silky smooth chocolate filling nestled inside a buttery crust. Each bite is rich and velvety, making it the dessert you want to linger over with a hot cup of coffee. Grandma secretly adores this pie because it feels indulgent yet timeless, perfect for chilly fall evenings.
Get the Recipe: Chocolate Cream Pie

Instant Pot Apple Pie Cheesecake

Instant Pot apple pie cheesecake takes the best parts of two desserts and blends them into one creamy, spiced masterpiece. The rich cheesecake base pairs perfectly with the sweet apple topping, creating a show-stopping fall treat. Grandma may smile at apple pie, but this is the one she’ll actually ask for seconds of.
Get the Recipe: Instant Pot Apple Pie Cheesecake

Mock Apple Pie

Mock apple pie is a clever twist that uses Ritz crackers to mimic the flavor and texture of apples in a spiced filling. It’s a nostalgic recipe that shows creativity in the kitchen while still tasting like a true fall pie. Grandma secretly loves serving it just to see the surprise on everyone’s face when they learn the secret ingredient.
Get the Recipe: Mock Apple Pie

Blackberry Crumble Pie

Blackberry crumble pie combines a juicy, tart berry filling with a buttery bottom crust and a spiced crumble topping. The mix of textures, flaky, gooey, and crunchy, makes it stand out on any holiday dessert table. Grandma loves how it delivers all the coziness of fall in one slice without being the usual apple pie.
Get the Recipe: Blackberry Crumble Pie

Pecan Pie with Maple Syrup and Maple Dulce de Leche Cream

Pecan pie takes Southern inspiration with bourbon, maple syrup, and toasted pecans layered in a flaky crust. A drizzle of maple dulce de leche cream brings extra warmth and sweetness to every bite. Grandma happily chooses this pie because it’s both decadent and thoughtful, making sure everyone at the table can enjoy dessert.
Get the Recipe: Pecan Pie with Maple Syrup and Maple Dulce de Leche Cream

Cinnamon Pie

Cinnamon pie wraps all the best fall spices into a creamy filling that’s smooth, fragrant, and just sweet enough. Nestled in a flaky crust, it feels like biting into a warm hug on a crisp autumn day. Grandma secretly favors this pie because it turns a simple spice into something extraordinary.
Get the Recipe: Cinnamon Pie

Chocolate Pie

Chocolate pie is pure comfort, with a dense, rich filling that’s both sweet and slightly bittersweet for balance. Served with whipped cream on top, it’s the kind of pie that makes any gathering feel more special. Grandma has a soft spot for this one because it never fails to please a crowd.
Get the Recipe: Chocolate Pie

Mississippi Mud Pie

Mississippi mud pie layers chocolate upon chocolate, with a fudgy filling, cookie crust, and whipped topping that’s impossible to resist. It’s decadent without being complicated, which makes it a go-to for family get-togethers. Grandma loves how it feels a little indulgent but still fits right in with the cozy fall dessert lineup.
Get the Recipe: Mississippi Mud Pie

Grape Pie

Grape pie celebrates Concord grapes in a flaky crust, offering a nostalgic recipe that feels straight out of a farmhouse kitchen. The sweet-tart filling bursts with flavor and pairs beautifully with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. Grandma treasures this pie for its old-fashioned charm and bold seasonal taste.
Get the Recipe: Grape Pie

Apple Pie Stuffed Cheesecake

Apple pie stuffed cheesecake takes the comfort of spiced apples and layers it with creamy cheesecake in one indulgent dessert. Each slice is rich, decadent, and perfect for when you can’t choose between pie and cake. Grandma secretly loves serving this because it feels like two cozy desserts rolled into one.
Get the Recipe: Apple Pie Stuffed Cheesecake